Black woman had lease revoked, was subjected to harassment, due to race


August 2, 2023

Black woman had lease revoked, was subjected to harassment, due to race

PHRC approves Office of Attorney General settlement

HARRISBURG – The Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission (PHRC) announced today it has approved a $90,000 settlement reached by Attorney General Michelle Henry's office over allegations that a Shippensburg landlord discriminated against a Black family, attempting to block their move-in, and harassing them at the property.

In addition to paying $90,000, landlords John Timothy Gruver and Bonnie Gruver, their son and daughter-in-law Robert and Kelly Gruver, and Ridgway Real Estate are required to receive fair housing training provided by the PHRC and abide by new fair housing policies.

"The PHRC is committed to fairly and impartially investigating complaints on behalf of complainants and respondents alike, and I applaud the AG's office, the PHRC's staff, and the respondents in this case for arriving at this resolution," said Chad Dion Lassiter, Executive Director of the PHRC. "Discrimination in all forms is not tolerated in Pennsylvania."

Attorney General Henry added, ""Housing discrimination prevents families from accessing a basic necessity — a comfortable, secure place to live — and has no place in the Commonwealth. Unfair screening methods and harassment against Pennsylvanians paying hard-earned dollars to live freely will not be tolerated, and offenders will be held accountable under our fair housing laws."

The complainant contacted the Office of Attorney General in May 2020, during the early months of the pandemic shutdown, alleging that the landlords discriminated against her and her grandchildren by revoking their lease shortly before the move-in date due to her race and concerns that one of her grandchildren had been in trouble with the law. The complainant said she tried to explain that that grandchild would not be living with her, but the landlord would not listen.

Believing she still had a legally valid lease, she went to the property on her move-in date. The real estate agent had placed a "No Trespassing" sign on the door, naming her by name. In addition, the landlords' son and daughter-in-law, Robert and Kelly Gruver, who lived next door, confronted the complainant and allegedly racially harassed her and used a slur.

The Office of Attorney General's Civil Rights Enforcement Section filed complaints with the PHRC. The Office contended John and Bonnie Gruver's revocation of the lease violated the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act's (PHRA) prohibition against racial discrimination in housing by intent and/or unjustified disparate impact. The Office also contended that Ridgway Real Estate aided and abetted the PHRA violation because its agent knew or should have known that the landlords' reasons for voiding the complainant's valid lease were racially discriminatory, yet the agent took actions to facilitate and enforce the decision rather than oppose it. Finally, the Office contended that Robert and Kelly Gruver subjected the complainant to racial harassment that violated the PHRA.

The PHRC found probable cause to credit the Office of Attorney General's allegations. After conciliation talks initially failed, the PHRC's staff counsel joined the Office of Attorney General as a co-litigant to present the case at a Commission hearing, as permitted by the statute. The parties then conciliated the matter successfully prior to a hearing, and on July 24, 2023, the Commission approved the conciliation agreement and entered it as a Final Order.

The respondents denied the allegations and entered into the conciliation agreement to avoid litigation.

This matter was handled by former Deputy Attorney General Catherine Twigg of the Office of Attorney General's Civil Rights Enforcement Section, under the direction of Chief Deputy Attorney General Corbett Anderson. PHRC Deputy Chief Counsel Morgan Williams handled the matter on behalf of the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission.

The PHRC, the state's leading civil rights enforcement agency, urges anyone who has experienced acts of discrimination or hate to file a complaint with the PHRC by calling 717-787-4410.  Information and resources are also available at


PHRC Media Contact Details

Amanda Brothman

Communications Director 771-856-5971
Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission Media